School Board Chairman: 'You Get a Great Bang for Your Buck'
Majority of voters agree, and support schools' budget request.
Westborough School Committee Chairman Ilyse Levine-Kanji's "You get a great bang for your buck"-themed budget presentation Saturday apparently resonated with voters.
The annual town meeting approved school officials' budget request of $42,694,208, a 3.1 percent increase from current spending.
Voters had three school budget options: the school department's request; the advisory finance committee's recommendation of $42,521,400; a 3 percent increase; and resident Dominic Capriole's proposal of $42,108,000.
Town Moderator Joe Harrington said voters would discuss all three numbers simultaneously, but vote on the largest number first, and end the voting if a majority supported it, per Westborough's bylaws.
"The purpose of public education is an investment in the youth generation of this town, this state and this country,” Westborough High School senior Mark Aronson said.
“You guys are trusting us that we will make your lives better when we're out in the world. I think in Westborough, the general consensus of the student body is that the town is doing a great job with that.
"The schools need to be able to change and innovate along with businesses and companies. the only way they can do that is if they have the financial flexibility to be able try out new programs, invest in new technologies.”
Levine-Kanji’s presentation ranged from the schools’ achievements, to "show you what an excellent return we all are getting as taxpayers"; to the cost of meeting state and federal mandates; to special education costs; to transportation costs; and to the school department’s cuts in recent years.
She said School Superintendent Marianne O’Connor, in preparing her budget recommendation, "met with principals, and only considered the most basic requests," from which she cut more than $250,000. The school committee then cut O'Connor's budget by more than $500,000, Levine-Kanji said.
"But, most of you here are seeing our number for the first time this evening,” she said.
The $172,808 difference between the school and advisory finance committee budget recommendations represented 5.3 cents on Westborough’s tax rate, or “less than $2 per month for the average family tax bill,” Levine-Kanji said.
Advisory Finance Committee Chairman Edward Behn said the two boards worked collaboratively during the budget preparation.
"I don’t want this to become a confrontation,” he said.
“In the end, we're all one town, and we're all trying to do the best we can with the resources that we have."
Behn said that "the finance committee is not recommending a cut in the budget, but to limit the increase to 3 percent,” which the majority deemed "a reasonable number from the base.”
"Taxpayers in Westborough have always supported an outstanding school system, and the school system has delivered. They do a wonderful, wonderful job,” Behn said.
Capriole, meanwhile, said his recommended figure was one suggested by finance board member Peter Allen during budget discussions this winter.
Allen disputed that.
“Early in the discussions with the finance committee, I basically indicated that number was something below which I could never agree, but I was interested in hearing the opinions of the other finance committee members," said Allen, who said he supported the finance committee number.
Capriole asked to "have these two proposals discussed before I say anything. I'd like to get a sense of the audience here.”
"You've given us a number, and I think you ought to tell us why,” Town Moderator Joe Harrington replied.
Capriole said the municipal budget met the selectmen’s goal of staying within a 2 percent increase in total taxes, not counting new growth in the base.
The schools’ requested budget increase exceeds that target, Capriole said.
"I think we have to coalesce around one goal rather than split the town around two separate goals,” he said.
One resident asked the fincom what it would cut from the school budget.
"I don't think the town wants to say goodbye to the hockey team or the football team or some of the fine arts programs,” the man said.
Finance Committee Vice Chairman John Arnold said "it really would be the finance committee micromanaging for us to say specifically what would we do.”
Resident Paula Less said she supported implementing a $200 per student, with a $500 per year max transportation fee, as discussed by the school committee this fall.
"The people that are driving their kids to school today drive them because they want to,” Less said.
“If you want to keep the school at the level that it is and can continue at, you have to put the burden on the people who utilize the system. We are one of the only towns around that does not have a bus fee."
Resident Nate Walsh said other school districts have programs Westborough lacks but could use; in one district, "every kid is given a laptop.”
"The school department is doing a good job with what we give them, but we have to give them what they need,” Walsh said.
Dominic Capriole
1:34 am on Tuesday, March 19, 2013
Did a fire alarm go off immediately after the vote because it appeared that about 300 people got up and ran out of the hall? Texted bomb threat? Help me here folks. What did I miss?
Scott
4:16 pm on Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Might have been that there were many, many children in the high school gym awaiting their parents' attention. Also might have been that no one wanted to spend another second listening to you. Don't you take a hint when the Moderator asks you to please wrap it up and make a point? Other than enjoying listening to the sound of your own voice, you may want to focus on making an actual point rather than just rambling on & on.
Dominic Capriole
5:12 pm on Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Why would children be at Town Meeting? The author of the above article listed a few of my many points. The more you are able to listen the less I will need to speak. Please review the tape of the event and report back on who made the longest presentation.
TBH
10:42 am on Thursday, March 21, 2013
why would children be at Town Meeting? If you have to ask that question, then you do not know the demographic of the Westborough population that cared enough to come out to vote. Until you can enlist the aid of your "400" and beyond, which is an entirely different demographic, things will not change in your favor. Plain and simple and pretty much how any election or democratic process works.
Dominic Capriole
1:06 pm on Thursday, March 21, 2013
TBH,
You need to correct your post to read, "population that benefited enough at the expense of others to rush out to vote for one motion only." And add "This will backfire over time as the victims of this behavior will move away or die and this said population becomes the new victims."
Michael Gelbwasser
4:25 pm on Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Please do not make personal attacks. This story was about the school budget debate, not a particular speaker. Thank you.
arthur
9:31 am on Thursday, March 21, 2013
It's an unqualified statistic unless you can define what is included in the spend and what the size of the town is. Smaller towns can easily spend more per pupil with higher overhead and smaller population. It doesn't mean anything.
Michael Gelbwasser
8:02 am on Friday, March 22, 2013
I've removed a comment that was flagged by a user as inappropriate.